Ready?
Here's why I teach my daughter that Santa Claus, Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy and all the rest of the gang are fake.
Yes, fake. You read it right. Not real. As in, Eva knows that when the 'tooth fairy' leaves her coins under her pillow - yup, that was Mommy.
P.S. This happened tonight (and inspired this post) and I just LOVE when Eva looses a tooth. I don't know who is more excited about it - her or me.
Now before you go all crazy on me and insist that I am the stealer of imagination, killer of dreams and murderer of all things precious in my kids' childhoods - - just hear me out. I do have a few reasons which I will outline now, quickly, before you all end up unfriending me and covering your children's ears and eyes when you pass me at the store.
1. I won't lie to my kids. Sorry. That one pisses people off sometimes. Naturally, no one is intentionally lying to their kids when they tell them Santa REALLY comes down the chimney and leaves presents - but, in my books, it's a tad hypocritical. I can't very well teach Eva that lies are wrong - even white ones, even ones where you are trying to spare someone's feelings - and then turn out to be lying to spare hers ALL ALONG.
"Awww... but you're stealing the magic!!" No. Just. No. I hate when people tell me that. This was not a decision I made through laziness nor spite. I LOVE the holidays. I LOVE imagination. Santa still visits our house; as does the Easter Bunny and Elf on the Shelf and the Tooth Fairy. BUUUUUT... here's the clincher. They visit us but Eva knows that it's really me. Ruin the magic, does it? Lessens the fun, huh?
So you're saying Christmas Eve we get into our jammies, read The Night Before Christmas, bake cookies and leave them out with milk, leave out carrots for the reindeer, Eva FINALLY falls asleep after giggling and singing and talking and altogether keeping herself awake for hours our of sheer excitement - then, the second that first sun beam kisses her brow and she jets out of bed to look at all the amazing presents wrapped under the tree in their paper wrapped, bow adorned glory - you're telling me that she will sigh and say, "Whatever. Those are just from you, Mom and Dad. Lame."
??
It's just not true. You can have all the magic of Christmas and holidays without the literality of it. A man doesn't LITERALLY need to come down your chimney for Santa to be magical. A winged fairy doesn't LITERALLY need to be flying through your window at night to give you coins for teeth (which, in fact, if you think about it? Creepy much?) A bunny doesn't LITERALLY need to poop out candy. Make believe is still fun without being 100%, entirely, without a doubt convincing. When we play dress up, I don't suddenly have a Doctorate and if someone had a heart attack Eva wouldn't believe that I magically had the skills to save them. That doesn't make playing Doctor any less fun!
Think of it this way. This is how I explained it to Eva: She was 3. A very precocious 3 year old, mind you; which is where all this started. I knew I had little time before she figured out everything - her little toddler eyes peered into my very soul.... What with our family situation being as it was, I couldn't fabricate a father for her out of thin air, nor have the heart (or blind stupidity) to fabricate a story about why that was false. I decided to tell her the truth (as much of the truth as a 3 year old can stomach, I'm not cruel, peeps, promise). I needed a plan. She loved Dora. After we finished watching an episode of Dora, I ventured this to her:
"Oh, Eva. I sure love watching Dora with you. But... do you think, maybe, Dora would ever come to our house?"
She looked up at my inquisitively, her gears turning.
"Like, in real life. Is Dora going to come to our house?"
Pondering.
"What do YOU think?"
A big smile. "No, Mommy! That's silly. She's on t.v."
And so began the foundation of teaching her that Santa and his team are illusory. Does knowing that Dora isn't going to come knocking on our door make the show any less fun to watch? Alternatively, does believing that Dora REALLY is ALIVE and is out there somewhere with a talking pet monkey and friends make Dora better? (honestly, I don't think ANYTHING can make Dora good, but c'mon, we're talking at a 3 year olds level here...)
Also, I'd like to point out one other thing: I did NOT just up and say, "Hehehe you dumb little kid Santa isn't real mwhahahahahaHA!" There were no tears. No anger. No outward TELLING her, really. Like most things, I posed a thought or two to Eva and let HER brain do the work. If she can't get there on her own, SHE'S NOT READY. Her brain's not ready. It's that simple. No use pounding a screw in with a hammer.
2. I don't like the idea of Santa's lists. Again, sorry. I realize that some people LOVE Christmas time so they can drop a 'You don't want to be on the naughty list, do you??' to their kids every time an argument breaks out, but I just really don't agree with that style of parenting. I want my kids to WANT to be good because it's the right thing to do, not because they will get a barrage of gifts from a strange, fat man on Christmas morn. Payouts for good behavior? Not in my house.
3. Also, any and ALL of these pictures. Seriously. If your kid doesn't want to sit on Santa's knee - please, for the love of PB&J, stop FORCING it. Not to mention that I've never liked sitting on a strangers knee - not when I was a kid and certainly not for my own kid. If it's someone I know, fine, but we avoid mall Santas like the PLAGUE.
Okay, I also admit that sometimes this is just plain hilarity... but... also... kinda sad.
3. Insert paranoid-conspiracy-theory-esque-reason-about-Coca-Cola-and-corporate-money-making-schemes. Sorry guys. I believe it. I don't like it. I don't subscribe to it.
5. I like to believe my kids are smart. She's gonna figure it out soon anyway. Darn kid asks way too many deep questions already. She's the FIRST person to correct me when I'm wrong - last thing I need to do is give that smart alec more ammunition. The last thing I want is to have a 10 year old, figuring it out on her own, while I desperately try to cover my tracks so she doesn't 'find me out!'
4. Did I already mention it's hypocritical? I just don't get why we insist on teaching stranger danger and safety (we do live in a messed up world, peeps) and then romanticize once a year where a man LITERALLY COMES INTO YOUR HOUSE AND LEAVES YOU STUFF. And you take it all and open it all and eat it all and use it all and want more next year. Just cuz he watches you and you were good and all. Big brother, much? It's past 1984, guys...
Okay, I realize this has become a rant about Santa. But ALL the corporate mascots apply - Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy and all. Why do they deserve the credit? Sheesh. I paid for those gifts. I made those treats. I stayed up until midnight and wrote that note and crept silently into your room and under your pillow, cat stealth style, without waking you up. I was the bomb. I deserve the credit. (Selfish, much?)
Now, I realize a lot of people's hesitancy also lies in the fact is the last thing we want is for our kid to ruin the magic for another kid at school. I HEAR THAT. Talk about my worst fear imaginable. The thought of Eva saying 'Santa isn't real' to another kid would give me chills. I needed her to understand that other kids literally believed in him and why. She needed to have the maturity to understand that and to know ruining that for them would be a terrible thing. So, I waited until she was ready. She's 7 now and she would never DREAM of saying anything to anyone about it.
For example: A few Christmases (Christmasi?) ago, Dallin's dad dressed up as Santa and showed up on our step. It was MAGICAL; even for me and I'm a grown woman! We were eating dinner, snow was falling. Suddenly we heard the faint jingle of bells.
jingle-jingle-jangle
We continue with our meal.
jingle-jingle-jangle - "ho-ho-ho!"
Our ears perk up. Looking back and forth to each other, wondering what on earth that was.
Louder:
"Ho! Ho! Ho!"
Eva's eyes are wide. Mine are wider. Dallin - well, he knew what the heck was going on the bum, so, he just rolled his eyes.
We glance out the window and through the blanket of snow we see a red-suited form making its' way through our backyard with a large sack flung on its' bag. I'm pretty sure I squealed. Eva probably just said, "What the heck is going on?!!"
We fling open the door. Santa emerges. In a flurry of "ho-ho-ho's" and snow swirling and dancing like glitter in our entry - hugs all around. Fast forward. Eva sits atop Santa's knee. They have their usual Santa-child discussion. She is beaming. She gets a gift. We all do. More hugs. Santa leaves.
As soon as the door closes, we hug more. The excitement is palpable for Eva and I - Dallin, meh. Not so much. Dummy.... But soon, Eva is soon heard to inquire, "Now, Mommy, is it safe to ask.... like, was that.. I dunno... Papa Lo?"
Dallin and I laugh. We ask her what she thinks.
"Well, yeah, I guess. I mean. He sounded like him. He kinda smelled like him. I think it was."
We confirm.
She beams all the more, "Ohman! I love him so much - he must really love me to do that for me!"
It brings tears to my eyes even thinking of it now. Hands down, that was one of the most magical and beautiful Christmas moments I have ever shared. I am so lucky to be able to have moments like that. And I'm so happy my daughter knows who exactly gave her that beautiful moment. I witnessed the love she had for her Papa Lo and Nana Jo grow exponentially - the thought that they would drive all that way to us (from Edmonton) and bring gifts and dress up was just unfathomable to her. It taught her a huge lesson about selflessness. Because that's what it should be about! I'm not saying for a second that Santa shouldn't BE - absolutely not! I enjoyed the heck out of that surprise Santa visit - Logan is Da Bomb at Secret Santa visits - and that should never cease. Like I've mentioned before, it's the literality of it all that gets me.
To end this altogether too long rant on Santa, I'd like to say that this is MY way of parenting that I've pored over, thought about and decided upon. It is NOT for everyone. It's an equation that works for my families happiness; it may not work for you. In other words, take all of this post spewage with a grain of salt. I don't think kids who believe in Santa are dumb, nor do I think their parents foolish or lazy. It takes more than one way to make the world go round.
I won't judge your equation for happiness, if you won't judge mine.